Our Story

Jeremy Reed, born in a small town in Illinois, has always had a “passion for fashion.” There is a favorite family anecdote about five-year-old Jeremey requesting dress clothes for Christmas, and subsequently wearing the dress clothes -ties and all- to kindergarten. In college, Jeremy majored in business, and having a good time. A former college football player, he’s now an avid golfer. As an adult Jeremy has all too often been frustrated with the lack of shopping options for men in his area, and at the same time desired someone could make shopping easier for him. Unable to find the solution to his desire Jeremy set out on a mission to fill the shopping void for himself and others, resulting in the birth of That Guy’s Secret. Busy That Guys don’t always have time to make it to the store, but they still like to look good. Noting this of his own life, he decided to add an online personal shopper subscription.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I don't like it/it doesn't fit?

Exchanges are always free. Simply stop in and see us, and we will fix you right up. If you can't make it in, send it back along with a description of the issue, and we will include a replacement in next month's box. 

Do I still get an in-store discount if I'm not a Platinum Member?

We appreciate all of our members! On all in-store purchases Silver Members will receive a 10% discount, Gold Members receive a 15% discount, and Platinum Members receive a 20% discount. 

Will the stuff be different every month?

Yes, it will be different. You won't end up with 20 of the same blue shirt. 

When do I get my package?

Packages ship on the Wednesday following your sign up date. Future shipments will correspond to your original sign up. i.e. If your sign up date was the 15th of the month then your future packages will ship the first Wednesday after the 15th of all future months. 

Can I change my membership?

Yes, you can. Simply go to the account tab, then click manage subscription.  This will allow you to change between subscriptions to better fit your needs. 


Can I purchase individuals items or only the monthly subscription?

Yes, you can purchase any of our items with or without purchasing That Guy's Secret Club membership.


Do I have to have my package shipped?

No.  If you would like to pick up your purchase in the store, please just add a note in the section labeled "special instructions to seller" and use promo code InStorePickUp.